Loading ...

The auto-renewal clause – when can it be deemed to be ‘unfair’?

This article was published in the Hire and Rental Industry Magazine August 2026, page 22 

Auto-renewal clauses are commonly found in hire agreements. They effectively roll over an agreement or master agreement at the end of its term unless notice is given. Notice is usually required in writing and to be given before the end of term. 

It is a clause that is convenient for hire companies, but can ‘catch out’ a customer if they have not noticed the clause or set a reminder to review the contract in time to see if they do not wish to continue with it. There are pros and cons to using an auto-renewal clause for both parties. However, in what circumstances can it potentially be deemed to be an unfair contract term?

The Pros

The auto-renewal clause:

  • reduces the need to renegotiate agreements

  • locks in a long-term customer

  • ensures continuity in the agreement

The Cons 

The same clause may:

  • lock a hire company into outdated pricing

  • be deemed unfair under the Australian Consumer Law when the customer is a consumer or small business (ie businesses with fewer than 100 employees or turnover under $10 million) and this term appears in your standard form agreement

  • result in the hire of the equipment being deemed to be a PPS Lease under the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (PPSA), particularly if that was not the intention.

Is it an unfair contract term?

The auto-renew clause may be found to be an unfair contract term by a court or tribunal if it:

  • creates a significant imbalance between the parties’ rights and obligations

  • is not reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the party advantaged by it

  • lacks transparency (ie is hidden, unclear or difficult to understand)

  • causes detriment (financial or otherwise) to the affected party if enforced

Case study: ACCC v JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd

In this case, the Court found that the auto-renew clause in JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd’s (JJR) standard form contract was unfair. 

The majority of contracts had durations that ranged from one year with one-year renewal periods to five years with five-year renewal periods, and indicated the contract would continue unless terminated by either party giving written notice within 30 days prior to the end of the initial or renewed term. 

The court found that the limited termination window for JJR customers, combined with the lack of requirement for JJR to provide notice to a customer of an impending renewal, may result in JJR customers missing the opportunity to terminate and therefore remaining contracted JJR for extensive periods.

In the context of the whole contract, the clause was found to create a significant imbalance. JJR would have been more aware of the contract renewal dates than small business customers, who may have limited resources and competing priorities. The clause was found to be exacerbated by other clauses in the contract such as price variation, exclusivity and termination clauses. Further, contracts with JJR customers were usually low value, with a low marginal cost to JJR, so it was found the auto-renewal clause was not reasonably necessary to protect JJR’s legitimate interests.

Careful drafting and whole context 

An auto-renew clause can be useful but needs to be carefully drafted and balanced with other clauses in a standard form contract that provides a consumer or small business with an opportunity to change suppliers in time and be made aware of when a contract is coming up for renewal. 

Author: Rebecca Hegarty

 

This publication is intended as a source of information only. No reader should act on any matter without first obtaining professional advice.